BMW of Shrewsbury

Certified Center

Home > BMW Models > BMW X3 > X3 vs Q5 vs GLC

BMW X3 driving on a New England back road in fall (AI-generated image)

BMW X3 vs Audi Q5 vs Mercedes-Benz GLC: Price, Power and Cargo Compared.

Pick the BMW X3 for the most cargo space and the best all-around drive in Edmunds' 2025 test. Pick the Audi Q5 for the most base power and a sliding rear seat, or the Mercedes-Benz GLC if an upscale cabin matters more than cargo space.
31.5 cu ft
BMW X3 cargo, row two up
27.6 cu ft
Audi Q5
21.9 cu ft
Mercedes-Benz GLC
1st
BMW X3 in Edmunds' 2025 test

Each maker's site, updated November 2026. Edmunds, September 12, 2025, testing 2025 models.

The short answer

Best all-around

BMW X3

Choose it for the most cargo space of the three, 31.5 cu ft behind row two, standard xDrive, and first place in Edmunds' 2025 test.

Audi Q5

Choose it for the most base power, 268 hp, the quickest base 0 to 60 at 5.8 seconds, a sliding rear seat and 3 years of included maintenance.

Mercedes-Benz GLC

Choose it for the cabin Edmunds called upscale and a Transparent Hood camera view, with the least cargo space of the three at 21.9 cu ft.

BMW X3 seen from the rear three-quarter, driving a winding back road (AI-generated image)

The numbers that decide it

Swipe to see all three.

SpecBMW X3Audi Q5Mercedes-Benz GLC
Starting MSRP$51,300Leader$53,300$54,400
Base engine255 hp268 hpLeader255 hp
0 to 60 mph6.0 sec5.8 secLeader6.0 sec
Cargo behind row two31.5 cu ftLeader27.6 cu ft21.9 cu ft
Highway fuel economy33 mpgNot yet rated31 mpg
Included maintenance3 yr / 36,000 miLeader3 yr / 30,000 miSold separately

Base all-wheel-drive versions: X3 30 xDrive (2026), Q5 TFSI quattro (2027), GLC 300 4MATIC (2027). Starting MSRP before destination. Each maker's site, updated November 2026. Audi had not posted 2027 EPA ratings.

What independent testers found

Edmunds tested the 2025 models of all three and ranked the BMW X3 first at 7.5 out of 10 and called it the "best all-around small luxury SUV." The Mercedes-Benz GLC placed second at 7.3 and the Audi Q5 third at 7.1 (Clint Simone, Edmunds, September 12, 2025). Those were 2025 models, a year older than the SUVs on our lot.

Where each one gives ground

BMW X3. It starts lowest, at $51,300, and carries the most cargo. Its 255 hp base engine trails the Audi Q5's 268 hp, and the Q5 reaches 60 mph 0.2 seconds sooner.

Audi Q5. It wins on base power and on Audi's 3-year, 30,000-mile included maintenance. It gives up on driving feel and efficiency, which Edmunds called "so-so," placing it third.

Mercedes-Benz GLC. It wins on its interior, which Edmunds called upscale. It gives up the most cargo space here, 21.9 cu ft behind row two, and Edmunds rated it the least sporty of the three.

Drive all three in one week

  1. Take the same back road in each one.
  2. Merge onto the Mass Pike from the same on-ramp.
  3. Bring the same car seat or golf bag.
  4. Sit in the back seat, not just the front.

Questions shoppers ask

Which has the most cargo space?

The BMW X3, with 31.5 cu ft behind the second row, against 27.6 for the Audi Q5 and 21.9 for the Mercedes-Benz GLC, per each maker.

Which costs less to maintain?

BMW includes 3 years or 36,000 miles of scheduled maintenance, and Audi includes 3 years or 30,000 miles on the 2027 Q5. Mercedes-Benz sells prepaid maintenance in 2, 3 and 4-year packages.

What must an advertised price include in Massachusetts?

Every mandatory fee except taxes, per the Massachusetts Attorney General's June 2026 advisory to dealers.

Schedule a BMW X3 test drive

Drive the X3 on your usual roads, then compare it with the Q5 and GLC the same week.

We'll call or email to confirm an exact time.

Sources and fine print

Edmunds tested 2025 models of all three. Audi Q5 cargo is Audi's 2026 figure; Audi had not posted 2027 EPA ratings. Competitor figures are each maker's, updated November 2026.

Starting MSRP excludes destination, taxes, registration and dealer fees.